When I first started getting into writing and storytelling, I got some really good advice: “just write.” At first, I was all worried about whether my story made sense and where it was going, so I thought about making a clear plan. But as I went along this creative journey, I found that I really love the freedom of just letting the words flow, while also gaining a new appreciation for having an outline to follow. It’s pretty crazy how different organic storytelling and careful plotting can be!

Storytelling has been a fundamental human activity for millennia, evolving from oral traditions to intricate novels and screenplays. When it comes to crafting a narrative, writers generally fall into two camps: those who prefer organic storytelling and those who rely on a meticulous writing plan. Understanding the differences between these approaches can illuminate the diverse methods through which stories are born.

Organic storytelling, often referred to as “pantsing” (writing by the seat of one’s pants), involves creating a narrative without a predetermined structure. Writers who adopt this method allow their characters and plot to develop naturally, often discovering the story as they write. This approach can lead to a more fluid and spontaneous narrative, where the writer’s creativity is unbound by rigid outlines. The benefits of organic storytelling include the potential for unexpected twists and a more authentic emotional journey, as the characters evolve in real-time. However, this method can also pose challenges; without a clear direction, the story may wander or become inconsistent, requiring substantial revisions later.

In contrast, a writing plan, or “plotting,” involves a detailed outline before the actual writing begins. This method demands extensive pre-writing work, including character sketches, plot points, and sometimes even scene-by-scene breakdowns. Plotters value the roadmap this approach provides, ensuring that the narrative arc is coherent and that key themes and motifs are consistently developed. A writing plan can save time in the editing process since the writer has already addressed potential structural issues. However, this approach can sometimes stifle creativity, making the writing process feel more mechanical and less inspired.

Ultimately, the choice between organic storytelling and a writing plan depends on the individual writer’s preference and the specific demands of the project. Some writers may even blend the two, starting with a loose outline and allowing room for spontaneity. Both methods have their strengths and weaknesses, but they share the common goal of crafting compelling, meaningful stories that resonate with readers. Understanding these approaches can empower writers to find the process that best suits their creative needs.